The Architectures of Story wheel
Architectures of Story · Architecture Guide

∞Non-Conflict Architecture

An Architecture of Story

A world set down whole and lived in until it is trusted. Space is left open around it. Then something arrives from outside its logic, the whole is seen again, and the meaning lingers after the telling ends.

The established world is the story. It is set quietly and completely, deepened for its own sake, and given room. Then a turn sets something beside it from another angle, and the meaning comes from the two seen together: the whole reread, reconciled, and left resonating.
TimeEstablishment, then reframeProtagonistThe established worldResolutionReframe reveals meaningMovements6StoryWorlds it is built from4
Hekiunsan Ryōan-ji Temple 20210724 07
Hekiunsan Ryōan-ji Temple 20210724 07, 先従隗始, 2021-07-24 14:18:27 · Wikimedia Commons · CC0
The base

What Is an Architecture of Story?

An Architecture of Story is the shape of how a plot moves: not what happens, but the engineering logic of how it is built. It is not a genre, a theme or a style. It is the load-bearing shape underneath a plot, and it was found in the stories of the world's cultures, built up from the bottom.

Everything begins with a culture's own data: their stories themselves, their mythology, their nations and lineages, their history, their cosmology and the way they keep time. Each GriotsWell World Cultural (WC) StoryWorld is built from one culture's data and from no one else's. Lay the data of the StoryWorlds side by side and shapes show. Cultures on different continents, with no contact, move their stories the same way. Those shared shapes are the Architectures of Story.

Two stories from cultures who never met can answer the same four questions the same way. When they do, they share an architecture, however different their gods, landscapes and words.

  • How does time move?
  • Who is the protagonist?
  • How does meaning build?
  • What is resolution?
Non-Conflict answers the four questions

The shape of Non-Conflict

How does time move?
Establishment, then reframe

Time is placed in intervals. The world is set and held, the moment is given room, and then the turn arrives and everything before is reread at once. Three years in the Dragon Palace are three hundred on land; a whole life passes before the millet is cooked.

Who is the protagonist?
The established world

The protagonist is the world set down whole: the inn at Handan, the shore of Miho, the village at Tango, the oak at Crooked Shaft. The people in it belong to it, and it is the world that is finally seen anew.

How does meaning build?
By a turn that rereads everything before it

Meaning builds by setting things beside each other: the established world and something from outside its logic, the said and the unsaid, the dreamer and the dream. It gathers in the space left open and arrives with the turn.

What is resolution?
Reframe reveals meaning

The whole is seen again, the parts reconciled, and the understanding lingers. A way of seeing loosens, and the meaning stays with the listener after the last word.

The movement

Six movements, one turn

123456The WorldSet WholeThe WorldDeepenedThe SpaceLeft OpenThe TurnThe WholeSeen AgainThe Afterglow

The world is set and deepened along a line, and space is left open. The turn arrives from outside, marked in red, and lands where the whole is seen again; the dashed arc reaches back over everything before. The meaning spreads outward in widening rings of afterglow.

  1. 01The World Set Whole
  2. 02The World Deepened
  3. 03The Space Left Open
  4. 04The Turn
  5. 05The Whole Seen Again
  6. 06The Afterglow
The output

Where the steps lead

Every step of an Architecture of Story leads to one goal: your story, made in that architecture. Each movement you work through becomes part of the plot, with your own people, places and events, and together the steps give you the whole plot blueprint, ready to write from.

It is a restructuring, not a retelling. Bring a story you know and the steps rebuild it in the architecture, moving, changing and adding events wherever the shape needs them. Bring your own idea and the steps build it from the start. Either way the blueprint is the plot, and the story is written from it.

That is the purpose of the work: to make stories, and to see one story made in different architectures, or in a culture's own WC StoryWorld.

What Non-Conflict is

A world set whole, then seen again

In Non-Conflict, the story begins by setting a world down whole. A man lies down for an afternoon nap. A scholar sits on a mat in a roadside inn while the innkeeper's millet steams. A fisherman lives with his mother above a beach of drying nets. A carpenter walks past a great oak by a village shrine. A feather mantle hangs on a pine on the shore of Miho. Nothing is wrong. Then the world is deepened and lived in so fully that it is trusted: the butterfly is a butterfly through and through, Lu Sheng's whole life of office, exile and glory unfolds, the Dragon Palace shows all four seasons at once, Cook Ding explains how he meets the ox with his spirit.

Around all of it, space is left open. Ma, the meaningful interval, lets the unspoken carry as much as the spoken: the maiden's grief is shown only by the wilting flowers in her hair and the clouds she watches, the cook's blade with no thickness finds room between the joints. Then comes the turn. It arrives from outside the established logic, a shift of vista. Zhuang Zhou wakes and cannot say whether he is a man who dreamt a butterfly or a butterfly dreaming a man. Lu Sheng wakes and the millet is not yet cooked. Three years under the sea were three hundred on land. The useless oak speaks in a dream.

The close sets everything before beside the turn and sees the whole again. The parts are reconciled: man and butterfly are forms in the transformation of things, the timeless palace and the mortal shore meet in Urashima, the carpenter learns the use of the useless. Something is understood. And the ending lingers. The empty stage after the maiden rises past Fuji, the white smoke from the box, the proverb of the yellow millet dream carry the meaning past the last word, into the listener's own life.

Movement by movement

How a Non-Conflict story moves

01
Movement 1 of 6

The World Set Whole

A Non-Conflict story opens by setting a world down whole: its place, its people and its ordinary order. Nothing is wrong, and nothing needs to be. The established world is what the story is about.

In the stories
  • Zhuang Zhou, a minor official of the lacquer garden at Meng, lies down and sleeps. That is the whole frame: a man, a nap, an afternoon.
  • At a roadside inn at Handan, a young scholar in a coarse robe sighs over his lot beside an old Taoist, while the innkeeper steams a pot of yellow millet.
  • A fishing village on the coast of Tango: thatched houses, boats drawn up on the sand, nets drying, and Urashima Tarō living with his old mother.
  • On the shore of Miho in the spring haze, a fisherman finds a feather mantle hanging on a pine.
  • Carpenter Shi, travelling to Qi, passes a great oak by the village shrine at Crooked Shaft, so big that thousands of oxen could rest in its shade.
  • A priest walks to the shore at Ichi-no-tani, where years before he killed a young warrior. On the empty beach there is the sound of a flute.
  • An old man and his sharp-tongued wife live at the foot of the hills, and every evening the old man's pet sparrow sings to greet him.
Writing this movement

Qǐ and ki: the arising, the foundation. Zhuang Zhou lies down for a nap. A scholar sighs over his coarse robe at a roadside inn while millet steams on the stove. A fishing village above a beach of drying nets. The established world is the protagonist, so it must be given whole, with its textures, rhythms and settled expectations.

02
Movement 2 of 6

The World Deepened

The world is then developed for its own sake, lived in until it is trusted. The deeper the listener settles into it, the more fully it can later be seen again.

In the stories
  • In the dream the butterfly is a butterfly through and through, happy and doing as it pleases, with no shadow of Zhuang Zhou at all.
  • Inside the pillow, Lu Sheng lives a whole life: marriage, office, war, exile, recall, prison, pardon and fifty years of glory, told like an official biography.
  • In the Dragon Palace beneath the sea, each of the four directions shows a season: cherry blossom, cicadas, red maples, snow. Urashima stays, happy, for what feels like three years.
  • Cook Ding explains to Lord Wenhui how, after years, he no longer sees the whole ox but meets it with his spirit and follows its natural lines.
  • Carpenter Shi lists the oak's failures one by one: a boat of it would sink, a coffin would rot, a pillar would be eaten by worms.
  • Chunyu Fen sleeps off his wine on the veranda and lives twenty years as governor of Nanke in the Kingdom of the Great Pagoda Tree: a princess, five sons, honour, then war and the king's cold suspicion.
Writing this movement

Chéng and shō: continuing, developing. The butterfly is a butterfly through and through, with no shadow of the dreamer. Lu Sheng's whole dream life of office, exile and glory is told like an official biography. The Dragon Palace shows all four seasons. Cook Ding explains how he meets the ox with his spirit. The deeper the reader inhabits the world, the more fully the turn can reread it.

03
Movement 3 of 6

The Space Left Open

Space is left open. Ma, the meaningful interval, lets what is unsaid carry as much as what is said, and gives the turn room to arrive.

In the stories
  • In Hagoromo the maiden's grief is never spoken. The chorus shows only the jewelled flowers wilting in her hair and the clouds she watches as the wild geese fly home.
  • The fisherman's change of heart is never explained; he sees her weeping and is ashamed, and the meaning lies in the pauses after each line.
  • The Noh stage is bare: a polished cypress floor and a painted pine. The shore of Miho is made only by the chorus's words and the empty space where the audience sees it.
  • Cook Ding's blade has no thickness, and the joints have spaces: put what has no thickness into a space, and there is room to spare.
  • Lu Sheng lays his head on the porcelain pillow, and the opening at its end grows wider and brighter until he walks through it.
  • In Atsumori a young reaper vanishes before he can be named, and the stage is left empty while the priest prays through the night.
Writing this movement

Ma, the meaningful interval. In Hagoromo the maiden's grief is never said; the chorus shows her wilting flowers and the clouds she watches, and the fisherman's change of heart is never explained. Cook Ding's blade has no thickness and finds room between the joints. Lu Sheng lays his head on the pillow and its opening grows wide. What is left unsaid is a presence, and it gives the turn room to land.

04
Movement 4 of 6

The Turn

Then the turn. Something arrives from outside the established logic, a shift of vista that sets a new angle beside the world. It sets one thing beside another.

In the stories
  • Zhuang Zhou wakes, solid and unmistakably himself, and cannot tell whether he is a man who dreamt he was a butterfly or a butterfly dreaming he is a man.
  • Lu Sheng wakes at the inn. The old man is beside him, and the millet is not yet cooked.
  • Urashima returns to his beach and no one knows his mother's house: three years in the Dragon Palace were three hundred years on land.
  • That night the useless oak speaks to the carpenter in a dream: its uselessness is what has let it grow so great.
  • Asked to give back the mantle before the dance, the maiden answers that doubt is for mortals, and in heaven there is no deceit.
  • The ghost of Atsumori lifts his sword against the man who killed him, and stops: the priest has prayed for him all night, and they are friends in the Buddha's law.
  • The sparrow offers two baskets; the old man takes the small one home, and it is full of gold.
  • Chunyu Fen wakes: the servant is still sweeping, his friends are still washing their feet, the cup of wine is where he left it.
Writing this movement

Ten and zhuǎn: the turn. Zhuang Zhou wakes and cannot say which is the dreamer. Lu Sheng wakes and the millet is not yet cooked. Three years under the sea were three hundred on land. The useless oak speaks to the carpenter in a dream. The maiden answers: doubt is for mortals. The turn is a juxtaposition, something set beside the world from another angle.

05
Movement 5 of 6

The Whole Seen Again

Everything before is set beside the turn and seen again. The parts are reconciled, and the reader sees the whole again with new eyes.

In the stories
  • Between Zhuang Zhou and the butterfly there must be some distinction, and this is called the transformation of things: man and butterfly, waking and dreaming, each turns into the other.
  • Lu Sheng thanks the old man: now he understands favour and disgrace, gain and loss, life and death. He bows twice and goes on his way, content with the road to Handan.
  • Urashima opens the box and the white smoke turns him old in a moment. The timeless palace and the mortal shore are reconciled in him, and the ordinary village he left is seen as everything he had.
  • Lord Wenhui hears Cook Ding and says he has learned how to care for life: a life lived along its own grain does not wear itself out.
  • Everyone knows the use of the useful, says Zhuangzi; no one knows the use of the useless.
  • The old woman opens the heavy basket on the road and goblins spring out; every small kindness and cruelty before is seen again in the light of the two baskets.
  • Digging at the old tree's roots, Chunyu Fen finds the ant city and its king, the southern branch, and the princess's tomb, just where the dream had placed them.
Writing this movement

Ketsu and hé: concluding, uniting. Man and butterfly are forms in the transformation of things. Lu Sheng understands favour and disgrace, gain and loss. Urashima opens the box and becomes the age of the world around him, the palace and the shore reconciled in him. The carpenter learns the use of the useless. The understanding arises from the two things seen together.

06
Movement 6 of 6

The Afterglow

The ending lingers. Yoin, the afterglow, and the resonant close of Tang verse carry the meaning past the last word, into the world and into the listener.

In the stories
  • The maiden rises over the pines of Miho, past Fuji, into the haze, and the actor walks slowly off along the bridgeway. The silence after the last drum is part of the play.
  • The pine of Miho still stands, and Hagoromo is performed beside it each year, at night, by torchlight.
  • The Pillow tale gave Chinese the proverb of the yellow millet dream and travelled to Japan as the Noh play Kantan. It never says whether Lu Sheng's ordinary life will now be happy.
  • In Japan the tale of Urashima is told to children, and it stays with them as an image: a young man on the shore opening a small box, and the white smoke rising.
  • Zhuangzi drums on a basin and sings when his wife dies, because she has only been transformed, as spring turns to summer.
  • 'Pray for me again,' the ghost asks, and fades; what the flute played stays over the water after the stage is empty.
  • The tale of the Southern Branch ends on a warning to those who rise in rank: the whole of it may be an ant city under a tree.
Writing this movement

Yoin, the lingering resonance, and the resonant close of Tang verse. The maiden fades into the haze beyond Fuji and the stage is empty. The pine of Miho still stands, and the play is performed beside it by torchlight. The yellow millet dream became a proverb. Children remember the white smoke rising from the box. The ending is left open enough that the listener carries it on.

The craft

When Non-Conflict holds, and when it breaks

What makes it work

Set the established world down so completely, and live in it so fully, that the reader trusts it. Leave space open and let the unspoken carry meaning. The turn must come from another angle, something the established logic could not produce that still belongs once it is seen. At the close the parts are reconciled and everything before is reread, and the ending is left with the listener rather than stated.

What breaks it

A thin established world gives the turn nothing to reread. Filling and explaining every space is the second mistake. A turn that becomes a clash between opposing forces breaks it, and so does an arbitrary one where any surprise would have done. Avoid closing on a moral announced from outside, or shutting the ending so tightly that nothing lingers.

The StoryWorlds whose data built Non-Conflict

The cultures' own ways of telling

Each WC StoryWorld under Non-Conflict is its own culture's way of telling, carried in their own arts: the Japanese kishōtenketsu and ma, the Tang poets' four lines, and the parables of Zhuangzi.

Japanese — Ma (間)
The Japanese, in the aesthetics of ma carried through Noh, poetry, garden and painting · East Asia · Japan

Ma is the meaningful interval: the pause in Noh and music, the blank space of ink painting, the silence that carries more than speech. In Hagoromo the maiden's grief is never said; the chorus shows only her wilting flowers and the clouds she watches. The fisherman's change of heart is never explained. She dances into the empty stage, rises past Fuji into the haze, and the play ends on the bare stage and the silence after the last drum. Meaning lives in the space and in the afterglow, yoin.

Telling with care

Ma is a charged presence: the empty, the pause and the interval carry meaning as fully as what is filled. The space is left open rather than explained, and the ending lingers in afterglow rather than closing.

Japanese — Kishōtenketsu (起承転結)
The Japanese, who carried the four-part form of Chinese verse into their own poetry, essays, yonkoma and story · East Asia · Japan

Kishōtenketsu moves through foundation, development, turn and conclusion. In Urashima Tarō the fishing village is set whole, the Dragon Palace with its four seasons is lived in, and then the turn: three years under the sea were three hundred on land. The village of the opening is seen again as everything he had. When he opens the box, the timeless palace and the mortal shore are reconciled in him, and the image of the white smoke stays with every child who hears it.

Telling with care

The ten is a surprising juxtaposition and the ketsu a harmonious reconciliation of it. The four movements carry the story, and the turn is where its interest lives.

Chinese (Tang) — Qǐchéngzhuǎnhé (起承轉合)
The Chinese poets of the Tang era (618–907 CE) · East Asia · China

Tang poetics perfected qǐ, chéng, zhuǎn, hé: arising, continuing, turning, uniting, with the turning couplet opening a new vista and the closing couplet leaving resonance. In Shen Jiji's World Inside a Pillow, Lu Sheng lives fifty years of office, exile and glory in a dream, and wakes before the millet is cooked. He bows, thanks the old man and goes on his way, content with the road to Handan. The tale gave the language the proverb of the yellow millet dream.

Telling with care

Tang qǐchéngzhuǎnhé and Japanese kishōtenketsu share a root and are distinct traditions. The Tang turning couplet that opens a new vista, and the closing couplet whose meaning lingers, are its own.

Chinese (Taoist) — Zhuangzi Parables
The Taoist parables of Zhuangzi (Zhuang Zhou, c. 369–286 BCE), Warring States China · East Asia · China

Zhuangzi's parables set an ordinary frame and turn it. Zhuang Zhou dreams he is a butterfly and wakes unsure which is the dreamer; the contradiction dissolves into the transformation of things. Cook Ding's knife stays sharp for nineteen years because it moves through the spaces between the joints. The useless oak speaks to the carpenter in a dream. No argument is won: a fixed way of seeing is loosened, and the reader is left lighter.

Telling with care

Wu wei is effortless action in accord with the natural flow, an active harmony. The understanding at the close arises from the parable itself rather than being delivered as a moral. The Zhuangzi is philosophical parable, distinct from the pantheon of later religious Taoism.

Where a culture's art trusts the established world, the interval and the turn of perspective, their stories move by setting, deepening, turning and seeing again. For a writer, Non-Conflict is the architecture for stories whose meaning comes from understanding: a world shown fully, then seen from another angle, and left to resonate.

Terms

Words from the StoryWorlds

Ma (間)Japanese
The meaningful interval: the pause between sounds, the space between forms, the silence that carries meaning as fully as what is filled.
YohakuJapanese
The expressive blank space of ink painting, a full presence rather than an absence.
YoinJapanese
The lingering resonance and afterglow that carries meaning after the moment has passed.
NohJapanese
The classical theatre of masks, chorus and bare stage, whose pauses and restraint Zeami set out in his treatises.
Kishō, shō, ten, ketsuJapanese
The four movements of kishōtenketsu: foundation, development, the surprising turn, and the harmonious conclusion.
TamatebakoJapanese
The lacquered box Otohime gives Urashima, never to be opened; it held his years.
Ryūgū-jōJapanese
The Dragon Palace beneath the sea, where each direction shows a different season.
Qǐ, chéng, zhuǎn, héChinese (Tang)
Arising, continuing, turning and uniting: the four movements of Tang poetics.
Jueju and lüshiChinese (Tang)
The four-line quatrain and the eight-line regulated verse of Tang poetry, built on the four movements.
The turning coupletChinese (Tang)
The couplet of regulated verse that opens a new vista: zhuǎn.
ChuanqiChinese (Tang)
"Transmitting the marvellous": the Tang tales, among them Shen Jiji's World Inside a Pillow.
The yellow millet dreamChinese (Tang)
黃粱一夢: any glory that passes like a dream, the proverb the Pillow tale gave the language.
DaoTaoist
The Way: the source and pattern of all things, harmonized with rather than grasped.
Wu weiTaoist
Effortless action in accord with the natural flow; an active harmony.
ZiranTaoist
Being self-so: naturalness, spontaneity, things as they are of themselves.
WuhuaTaoist
The transformation of things, in which man and butterfly, waking and dreaming, turn into each other.
Sources

The stories behind Non-Conflict

Stories as told in the GriotsWell Book of World Mythology, and the arts recorded in the WC StoryWorlds under Non-Conflict.

  • The Butterfly DreamZhuangzi, chapter 2, "On the Equality of Things"
  • Cook Ding Carves the OxZhuangzi, chapter 3
  • The Useless TreeZhuangzi, chapters 1 and 4
  • The World Inside a Pillow (Zhenzhong ji)Tang dynasty tale by Shen Jiji (8th century)
  • Hagoromo, The Feather MantleNoh play attributed to Zeami
  • Urashima TarōJapanese folk tradition; Yei Theodora Ozaki, Japanese Fairy Tales (1908)
  • AtsumoriNoh play attributed to Zeami Motokiyo; the battle from The Tale of the Heike
  • The Tongue-Cut Sparrow (Shita-kiri Suzume)Japanese folk tradition; Yei Theodora Ozaki, Japanese Fairy Tales (1908)
  • The Governor of the Southern Branch (Nanke taishou zhuan)Tang dynasty tale by Li Gongzuo (802)
  • The Noh pauseJapanese Noh theatre and Zeami's treatises on the art
  • Yohaku and yoinJapanese ink painting and aesthetic tradition
  • The jueju quatrain and Tang regulated verseClassical Chinese poetics of the Tang dynasty (618–907 CE)
Live examples

Non-Conflict at work

Tales set out in Non-Conflict's steps: each one either in the form it is, or translated into Non-Conflict from its own form.

The Fisherman and the Jinni translated into Non-Conflict
The Thousand and One Nights: 'The Fisherman and the Jinni', with the nested tale of King Yunan and the Sage Duban

A live example of Non-Conflict Architecture at work: the architecture's movements filled in for one story. In the form it is, The Fisherman and the Jinni is a Negotiation tale. Here the same tale is set down as a world made whole, a space left open and a turn, and the jinni's threat moves from the centre of the story to the edge of its meaning.

The Tongue-Cut Sparrow in Non-Conflict, the form it is
Japanese folk tale (Shita-kiri Suzume); Yei Theodora Ozaki, Japanese Fairy Tales (1908), public domain · the form it is

This is The Tongue-Cut Sparrow in the form it is, Non-Conflict. The Japanese telling moves in four parts, ki, shō, ten and ketsu: a world set out, a world lived in, a turn, and the whole seen again. Every movement is filled in below.

Non-Conflict Architecture · An Architecture of Story · The Academy · All the Architectures of Story